Why do two YouTube channels with the same views earn different amounts?
Creators often compare screenshots and wonder why another YouTube channel earns more with the same number of views. On the surface it feels unfair—but the system is not paying “per view” in a fixed way.
This guide breaks down the hidden factors that make one channel earn 10× more than another, even when their views look identical inside YouTube Studio.
🌍 1. Equal Views ≠ Equal Money on YouTube
YouTube does not have a universal “rate card” where 1,000 views always pay the same amount. Instead, advertisers bid differently depending on who is watching, what they are watching, and how likely they are to buy something. Two channels can hit 100,000 views each and end the month with completely different RPM.
H3 — Why screenshots are misleading
- They don’t show geography of viewers.
- They don’t show where the traffic came from.
- They don’t show how long people watched.
- They don’t show whether ads were actually served.
To really compare two channels, you have to compare audience type, not just view count.
📍 2. Audience Geography Changes RPM Dramatically
One of the biggest reasons two YouTube channels earn differently is where their viewers live. Advertisers pay more for audiences in countries where customers have higher spending power and where ad markets are more mature.
H3 — Typical trend (not exact rates)
- U.S., Canada, U.K., Australia, Germany → higher RPM ranges
- India, Philippines, Nigeria, Brazil, Indonesia → lower RPM ranges
If Channel A gets most of its views from the U.S. and Channel B gets most of its views from lower-paying regions, Channel A will almost always earn more with the same total views.
💼 3. Niche & Advertiser Intent: Not All Topics Are Equal
Advertisers pay more when they are selling high-value products or services. That means some niches naturally attract higher ad bids, while others attract cheaper, broad branding campaigns.
H3 — Example of high-intent niches
- Finance (investing, credit, business tools)
- Software & SaaS tutorials
- B2B marketing, funnel building, CRM tools
- Education & online courses
Compare that with broad entertainment, memes, pranks, and random compilations. They can go viral, but the viewers often aren’t ready to buy anything—not ideal for advertisers.
🎯 4. Video Length & Ad Slots Per Viewer
YouTube can show more ads on longer videos without harming user experience. That means a 10–15 minute video has more opportunities to serve pre-roll, mid-roll, and post-roll ads compared to a 3-minute clip.
H3 — Why 8 minutes is a key threshold
- Videos under 8 minutes → limited ad slots
- Videos over 8 minutes → eligible for mid-roll ads
If Channel A posts 12-minute tutorials and Channel B posts 3-minute clips, Channel A can often show 2–4× more ads per view. Even with equal views, the ad inventory is not equal.
⌛ 5. Retention, Watch Time & Session Quality
Advertisers want their ads in front of viewers who are really watching, not just tapping in and out. YouTube’s algorithm measures watch time and retention curves, and channels with stronger retention often qualify for better ad placement and more monetizable traffic.
H3 — Two channels, different retention
- Channel A: average view duration 7 minutes
- Channel B: average view duration 1 minute
Even if both channels have 100,000 views, Channel A gave advertisers a much longer window to show ads and build brand exposure. The system rewards that with stronger RPM over time.
📱 6. Shorts vs Long-Form: Different Monetization Logic
Many creators compare earnings without realizing that Shorts and long-form videos are monetized differently. Long-form relies on direct ad impressions per video, while Shorts use a shared revenue pool distributed across creators based on views and signals.
H3 — Why Shorts views often “pay less”
- Ads are placed between Shorts, not always on specific videos.
- Revenue is pooled and then split across millions of Shorts.
- Shorter watch time means fewer premium ad opportunities.
So if Channel A is long-form focused and Channel B relies mainly on Shorts, they can hit the same views but not the same revenue.
🚫 7. Limited Ads, Yellow Icons & Policy Filters
Two channels can upload similar topics, but if one frequently triggers “limited ads” or yellow icons, its effective RPM drops. YouTube’s ad-suitability system looks for risky language, topics, thumbnails, and metadata that advertisers may want to avoid.
H3 — Common triggers for limited ads
- Strong language early in the video
- Violence, crime, or shock content
- Medical claims, quick-rich schemes, or risky finance promises
- Suggestive thumbnails or titles
A “cleaner” channel often earns more with the same views simply because more brands are comfortable appearing on it.
🧠 8. Reused & AI-Heavy Content Often Earns Less
YouTube’s reused content and originality rules affect both monetization approval and long-term RPM. A channel that depends heavily on stock footage, TikTok re-uploads, auto-generated slideshows, or AI narration with minimal insight may be classified as low-value for advertisers.
H3 — What YouTube looks for
- Commentary, context, and teaching
- Unique storytelling and personality
- Transformative use of clips, not simple re-uploads
Channels that build a clear creative voice tend to see better monetization over time, even in competitive niches.
📊 9. Case Study: Two Channels, Same Views, Different Outcomes
Channel A — “Global Tech Tutorials”
- 100,000 monthly views
- Long-form videos (10–14 minutes)
- Audience mostly in U.S., U.K., Canada
- Educational content: SaaS, productivity tools, remote work
- Clean titles, non-controversial topics
Channel A earns strong RPM because advertisers selling software, subscriptions, and services compete heavily for this audience.
Channel B — “Random Viral Shorts & Clips”
- 100,000 monthly views
- 90% of views from Shorts
- Mixed global audience, heavy Tier 3 traffic
- Clips from trends, memes, and reactions
- Occasional limited ads due to edgy topics
Channel B grows fast in views but struggles to convert those views into high RPM because of traffic type, content style, and the monetization model for Shorts.
🧩 10. How to Increase Earnings Without Increasing Views
Instead of only chasing viral views, creators can deliberately design their channel for higher RPM. That means improving niche focus, cleaning up titles and thumbnails, and building content that attracts viewers with long-term interest—not just curiosity.
H3 — Practical steps
- Shift content slowly toward higher-intent topics in your niche.
- Stretch strong videos to 8–12 minutes without adding fluff.
- Improve intros so retention stays high past the first 30–60 seconds.
- Reduce risky or borderline topics that trigger limited ads.
- Use Shorts to grow audience, but guide viewers into long-form content.
Over a few months, many channels see RPM rise even when views stay the same, because the audience and content mix becomes more advertiser-friendly.
🔍 11. What You Should Actually Compare Instead of Just Views
When you look at another creator’s earnings, don’t just copy their view count goals. Instead, compare deeper metrics: RPM, top countries, average view duration, and how many videos are fully monetized.
H3 — Key questions to ask about your channel
- Which countries send you the most Watch Time?
- Are your best-performing videos fully monetized?
- Do you cross 8 minutes on your most valuable topics?
- Is your niche aligned with real products and services?
When you shift your thinking from “more views” to “better views”, your YouTube strategy becomes more sustainable and your earnings more predictable.
📱 Connect With ToochiTech
Follow ToochiTech for more structured explanations on YouTube monetization, CPM vs RPM, and creator income systems:
Disclaimer
This article explains how YouTube monetization varies between channels based on niche, geography, watch behaviour, and advertiser demand. Earnings examples are illustrative, not guaranteed. YouTube may update its systems, payouts, and policies at any time.
Always rely on your own YouTube Studio analytics and official YouTube documentation for the latest information about eligibility, RPM, and policy changes. This content is educational and does not provide financial or legal advice.
Comments
Post a Comment